Complete simulation / SCL–7PB–0017
Profit leak & acquisition decision
Should Northline Home Services increase advertising to restore growth?
PROFIT BRIEFNot a customer result
Executive answer
Do not increase advertising yet.
Hold lead volume constant for 30 days. Replace the discount-led quote with a three-level value architecture and a consistent quote protocol. The evidence indicates that demand is reaching the business, but offer uncertainty and uncontrolled discounting are suppressing realized contribution after qualification.
Evaluation record
See how the conclusion was built.
The leak begins after qualification.
Lead volume remained broadly stable. Close rate and realized price declined after the discount-led offer became the default quote.
The largest addressable drop occurs between quote and close. Adding leads feeds the same loss point.
30-Day Recovery Plan™
A sequenced test—not a pile of recommendations.
Each phase produces evidence required by the next. Scaling is conditional, not automatic.
Instrument
Freeze the current lead mix. Add quote-version and objection fields to the pipeline export.
Clean baselineBuild
Convert the discount-led offer into three value anchors with explicit scope and tradeoffs.
Test-ready offerPilot
Use the new structure on 20 qualified opportunities without changing ad spend.
Comparable cohortChallenge
Compare close rate, realized price, cycle time, and cancellation rate against baseline.
Go / revise signalScale
Roll out only if contribution clears the $3,200 monthly floor and guardrails remain intact.
Controlled releaseLimits & review triggers
A good brief shows where it could be wrong.
- Pricing elasticity is inferred. No controlled price test exists in the fictional record.
- Public competitor pricing is incomplete. Visible entry prices may exclude common add-ons.
- Seasonality is only partially controlled. The six-month window does not cover a full annual cycle.
- Update trigger: rerun the decision after 20 comparable quotes or any 15% lead-mix shift.
This was the simulation.
Your brief starts with your evidence.
Bring the numbers, the documents, the contradictions, and the decision that matters.
Open a private briefing room